Why the STAAR Test is Bad

by | Oct 12, 2023

Ever since the STARR test replaced the TAKS test, it has come under critique for a number of reasons. I want to discuss some reasons why the STAAR test is a bad benchmark for students.


The STAAR test is the original replacement for the TAKS test. Chron.com had this to say about the TAKS (Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills):

Beginning with the 2011-2012 school year, students in the graduating class of 2015 will take the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness (STAAR), which will be “significantly more rigorous than previous tests,” according to a Texas Education Agency press release.

The TAKS test came under scrutiny from the TEA as being too easy so they decided to replace the test with the more up-to-date assessment: STAAR.

The STAAR Isn’t Accurate

Many teachers have cited that the STAAR exam isn’t actually accurate to the grade level being test. Reading passages alone have been assessed to be 2-3 years ahead of the grade level being administered. While the TEA is under pressure to produce results to prepare the next generation of workers for success, the STAAR isn’t offering an accurate or fair assessment for student readiness.

Another reason why the STAAR test isn’t deemed accurate is because it’s a “one-and-done” assessment. The test does not account for students who have poor test taking skills, or excel in other areas outside of the test. It also does not factor in outside influences that affect student performance. A student’s home life, mental state, and physical state all contribute to the performance of a student.

Other Downsides

The STAAR exam presents other downsides both inside and outside of the classroom. One critique teachers have is that it encourages teaching to the test. This is bad as teachers have less flexibility in teaching lessons and concepts outside of those that would strictly help students on the test. This is bad because as stated before, the exam doesn’t cover every aspect of a student’s knowledge. It encourages these “gaps” that would later harm a student’s academic habits and knowledge later in life.

Another large downside is the fact that it has no impact or indication of a student’s future. Universities and employers alike won’t ask to see your STAAR scores so they hold no real importance for a student’s long term academic or professional career.

The Future For STAAR

The future for the STAAR test is unclear. The TEA is always making changes with each new addition so the test will most likely evolve over the next decade. However, one thing to note is that the pressure for taking standardized tests is easing as time goes on. Many colleges are even going “test-optional” which means student’s do not need to submit SAT or ACT scores during the application process. While I cannot guarantee the future of standardized tests, I do believe it will continue to change and evolve (hopefully for the better).


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

What is Self Management For Students

So what is self management? Self management is a general term that encompasses a multitude of different aspects. Self management falls under the umbrella term of executive functioning that is learned in middle school. While self management is best learned early on in...

read more
What is Senioritis? | Tips to Prevent Burnout

Senioritis is a phenomenon that often creeps up on high school seniors as they approach the final year of their academic journey. It manifests in various ways, from a lack of motivation and focus to a feeling of being "checked out" from school work. While some...

read more

Real Teachers As Your Tutor!

Unlock your full potential and see progress today!